Last night was Neil Diamond night on Idol (WOOHOO!) and each contestant got to sing two songs. The plan, originally, was that the judges wouldn’t comment on the first round of songs and instead give a more complete critique after the second song of both.

After everyone performed the first round, Ryan brought all the contestants out onto the stage and asked the judges what they thought.

Remember… At this point, they’ve only performed one song.

Video below…

(Video replaced with Youtube vid for easiness sake; if it disappears, I’ll make other plans)

I don’t know what was going on with her, but not only did she get wrong the number of songs, she had a complete set of harsh criticism to go along with the second song Castro never performed!

Wow. Just wow.

I could see if she just said “Oh, I meant my second critique, not the second song,” but she did herself no favors when she said, “I thought you sang twice!”

Cringeworthy.