Recent Comments

Blogroll

Gruber Hypocritical About Links

John Gruber’s Daring Fireball blog got hot over TUAW linking to partner site (Engadget) rather than the original source of of story, calling out the attribution failure as “crummy.” After drawing attention to the issue, he noted in an update that TUAW had fixed the link to make it “slightly more clear” who the original source was.

However, Gruber doesn’t like to link to my articles, so when he couldn’t resist but draw attention to the original piece I wrote up on Microsoft’s Danger fiasco, he posted a link to what was very obviously a linkjacked version on another site, which itself noted that it was not the original source of the story, stated the original source, but then failed to actually link to the original work.

When contacted to correct the attribution, Gruber refused to update his link.

Isn’t this the guy who assigns a “Jackass of the Week?”

Bad Vincenzo for copying the whole thing, and I’m sure Daniel Eran Dilger will forgive me, but it proves something I’ve said pretty much forever.

John Gruber is a jackass.

Posted via Posterous

Bookmark and Share
  • I've always had problems deciding where to credit sources that link to sources that link to sources.

    Generally speaking, unless the place I got it from links to some "big obvious original source" like say, the New York Times or Fox News, I'll link to the place I found it.

    This is mostly for two reasons. If I found the original story, I'm probably referring to it without quoting a lot because I don't like to use excessive snippets. If people want to read the whole thing they will.

    If I can't find the original story it generally means the story isn't really "big enough" that anyone is going to care about clicking through to the source anyway.
blog comments powered by Disqus